Caste, Conservative, Colonial, and State Paternalism in India's Alcohol Policies

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55763/ippr.2022.03.05.004

Abstract

Alcohol consumption in India is governed by social and moral codes and religious norms, stratified by caste and gender, and controlled by state policies. Indian alcohol policy today consists of measures ranging from high taxation to strict prohibition across different states. Our article examines whether the Western state paternalistic framework is adequate to explain the alcohol policies of India. We conduct a critical reading of texts on socio-cultural and political history of alcohol consumption, taxation, and regulation in India, and study their influence on contemporary alcohol policies of Indian states. A central theme presented in this paper is that India’s complex history, with social institutions of caste, religious conservatism, regional politics and colonialism, has created a unique complex of experiences related to alcohol, and argues for a greater alignment of Western paternalistic frameworks with Indian socio-political context. Broadly, we argue that state paternalism should be understood beyond the national and state politics of the present, and factor in the path-dependency of socio-cultural and political history of the state being examined.

Keywords:

Alcohol Policy, Alcohol taxation, Paternalism, Caste Paternalism, Colonial Paternalism

Authors Bio

Shivakumar Jolad, FLAME University

Shivakumar Jolad is an Associate Professor of Public Policy at FLAME University, Pune. Prof. Shivakumar’s primary research interests are Data analytics, Education policy, and Human development. He studies the structural challenges faced by the government schools and examines ways to reorganize school system for better functionality. In recent years, he has worked on drain of enrollment in government schools in Karnataka, school consolidation, Right to Education, and learning level crisis.

Chaitanya Ravi, FLAME University

Chaitanya Ravi is Assistant Professor and Chair-Public Policy  at FLAME University. His primary research interests lie at the intersection of energy policy, climate policy, and international relations. He has a Ph.D. in Environmental Science and Public Policy from George Mason University where he was a Presidential Scholar from 2007-2010. His doctoral dissertation was a technological history of the debate over the US-India nuclear cooperation agreement. A revised version of the dissertation was published as a book (A Debate to Remember-The US-India Nuclear Deal) by the Oxford University Press-India.

References

Ambedkar, B.R. (1939). On Budget. Moon.V. 1982. Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar. Writings and Speeches. Volume 2 https://tinyurl.com/Ambedkar-Budget-1939

Ambekar, A., A. Agrawal, R. Rao, A. K. Mishra, S. K. Khandelwal, R. K. Chadda- as part of NDDTC and AIIMS. (2019). Magnitude of Substance Abuse in India. Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment- Government of India. https://tinyurl.com/MagSubUseIndia2019.

Austin, Granville. (1999). The Indian constitution: Cornerstone of a nation. Oxford University Press.

Bhattacharya, Nandini. (2017). The Problem of Alcohol in Colonial India (c. 1907–1942).

Studies in History, 33(2), 187-212. URL:https://tinyurl.com/Bhattacharya2017

Biruni, Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad. (1910).Alberuni's India, London : Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner& Co., 1910. Electronic reproduction. Vol. 1 and 2. New York, N.Y. : Columbia University Libraries, 2006.

CAD- Vol VII, (1948). Constituent Assembly Debates. https://tinyurl.com/CAD-Nov24-1948

Chari, Mridula. (2016, April 11). The long and twisted history of prohibition in Tamil Nadu.

Scroll. https://tinyurl.com/Chari-Scroll-2016

Colvard, Robert Eric. (2013). A World without Drink: Temperance in Modern India, 1880– 1940, PhD dissertation, University of Iowa, 2013

De, Rohit. (2018). A People’s Constitution: The Everyday Life of Law in the Indian Republic (Histories of Economic Life, 18). Princeton University Press.

Dworkin, Gerald. (2011). Paternalism. Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy. URL:http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/paternalism .

Eashwar, Anantha., R. Umadevi and S. Gopalakrishnan. (2020). Alcohol consumption in India- An epidemiological review. Journal of family medicine and primary care, 9(1), 49–55. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7014857/

Fahey, David and Padma Manian. (2005). Poverty and purification: the politics of Gandhi’s

campaign for prohibition. The Historian, 67(3), 489-506.

Gandhi, Mohandas. (1926). Total Prohibition, Young India, February 4, 1926, in Collected

Works of Mahatma Gandhi, 33.pp- 49. Quoted in (De, 2020)

Goldstein Research (2020, May 15): India Alcoholic Beverages Market Trends, Growth and

Forecast Analysis 2020-24. Goldstein Research , URL:https://tinyurl.com/GoldsteinIndiaAlcohol

Government of Maharashtra Excise Department. (2019). Current Duty and Fee Structure.

Mumbai: Government of Maharashtra. URL:https://tinyurl.com/MaharashtraExcise

Grill, K., J. Nihlen Fahlquist.(2012). Responsibility, Paternalism and Alcohol Interlocks. Public Health Ethics 5, no 2: 116–27. https://doi.org/10.1093/phe/phs015

Gururaj, Gopalkrishna, Melur S. Gautham, Banavaram A. Arvind.(2020).Alcohol consumption in India: A rising burden and a fractured response. Drug and Alcohol Review 40, no 3: 368–84. https://doi.org/10.1111/dar.13179 .

Hassan, B. (1922). The Drink and Drug Evil of India.

Hurst, John. (1889). The Temperance Question in India. The Century Magazine, vol. 38, 3. URL:https://tinyurl.com/Hurst-Temperance-1989

IIPS and ICF. (2017). National Family Health Survey (NFHS-4), 2015-16. Mumbai: IIPS. Retrieved fromhttps://tinyurl.com/IIPS2017

Janyala, Sreenivas. (2019, November 28). Explained: How a women-led movement influenced Andhra to reduce its liquor consumption. The Indian Express.

Kamei, Richard. (2014). Prohibition in Manipur: Deliberations over its “Dry State” Status.

Economic and Political Weekly, 49(52).

Kant, Krishna. (2020, May 5). Minting money: States earned Rs 1.75 trillion from sale of alcohol in FY20. Business Standard. from https://tinyurl.com/Kant-BS-June-2021

Kapeliushnikov, Rostislav. (2015). Behavioral economics and the ‘new’ paternalism. Russian Journal of Economics, 1(1), 81-107.URL: https://tinyurl.com/Kapeliushnikov2015

Kashyap, Karan. (2017, April 16). How Startups Are Catering To India’s $35B Liquour Market, The 3rd Largest In The World. Forbes. https://tinyurl.com/Forbes-Kashyap-2017

Kautilya and Rudrapatna Shamsastry(Translator). (2009). Kautilya’s Arthashastra (English). Unknown.

Kirchgässner, Gebhard. (2017). Soft paternalism, merit goods, and normative individualism. Eur J Law Econ 43, 125–152. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10657-015-9500-5

Kumar, Santosh. (2017). Price elasticity of alcohol demand in India. Alcohol and alcoholism,52(3), 390-395.

Lucas, Gary. (2011). Saving smokers from themselves: The paternalistic use of cigarette taxes. University of Cincinnati Law Review, Vol. 80 (693). URL: https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1942068

Manucci, Nicholas. (2010). Aurangzeb and prohibition. In: Kaul HK, editor. Historic Delhi: an Anthology. Delhi: Oxford University Press; 1996. p. 156–8

Nagaland Post. (2019, November 24). 30 years on: The Nagaland Liquor Total Prohibition

Act. Nagaland Posthttps://tinyurl.com/NagalandPost-Nov-2019

New, Bill. (1999). Paternalism and public policy. Economics & Philosophy, 15(1), 63-83

Nidheesh, M.K. (2015, November 30). How Indian states have fared in banning alcohol? Livemint. Available from https://tinyurl.com/MKNLivemint2015 (Accessed on 19 August 2020)

Pande, Mrinal. (2017, May 22). From the Vedic age to the Mughals and the Raj: The colourful history of alcohol consumption in India. Scroll. https://tinyurl.com/Pande-Scroll-May-2017

Poikolainen, Kari. (2021). Paternalism and alcohol policy. Drugs and Alcohol Today, Vol. 21 No. 1, pp. 6-14. https://doi.org/10.1108/DAT-07-2020-0048

Pope, Thaddeus.(2005). Is public health paternalism really never justified? A response to Joel Feinberg, Oklahoma City University Law Review, 30:1, 2005, p. 121.

Press Trust of India. (2019, May 28). Prohibition again imposed in Mizoram after four years.

India Today. https://tinyurl.com/PTI-IndiaToday-May-2019

Reserve Bank of India. (2019). State Finances: A Study of Budgets. Mumbai: Sangita Misra Reserve Bank of India. URL: https://tinyurl.com/RBIStateFinance2019

Saldanha, Indra (1995). On Drinking and 'Drunkenness': History of Liquor in Colonial India. Economic and Political Weekly, 2323-2331. URL:https://tinyurl.com/Saldania1995

Sharma, H,, B. Tripathi and Pelto, Pertti. (2010). The evolution of alcohol use in India. AIDS and Behavior, 14(1), 8-17. URL:https://tinyurl.com/Sharma2010

Sharma, Harikishan. (2020, May 14). ‘Explained: Why liquor sales matter to states’. The Indian Express. Retrieved fromhttps://tinyurl.com/IEMay1420 .

Singh, Magandeep. (2017). The Indian Spirit. Penguin Random House India Private Limited in dailyO. Retrieved on 30 June 2021 from https://tinyurl.com/Singh-DailyO-2017

Saxena S.L.(1948)., Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol VII, the 24th November.

Swamy, Rohini. (2017, June 8). Kerala says no to total prohibition: All about state’s new liquor policy. India Today. https://tinyurl.com/Swamy-IndiaToday-2017

Tekchand (1972) Liquor Menace in India. Gandhi Peace Foundation. New Delhi.

Tewary, Amarnath. (2016, April 1). Bihar to impose prohibition from April 2016. The Hindu. https://tinyurl.com/Tiwari-Hindu-2016

Thomas, Matthew and Luke Buckmaster. (2010).Paternalism in social policy when is it justifiable? Parliament of Australia. https://tinyurl.com/PopeAU2015

WHO. (2018). Global status report on alcohol and health 2018- Country Profile- India. World Health Organization.

Published

2022-09-23