Federal Dimensions of India's Response to the Covid Pandemic
Challenging the Idea of the “Flailing State”
This paper examines India’s responses to the Covid-19 pandemic, from the perspective of its federal structures. It first summarizes different institutional components of India’s federal system. Next, it outlines the responses to the pandemic, both over time, and across different levels of government. The main contribution of the paper is a new evaluation of the federal dimensions of India’s governmental responses at different levels. It is argued that, while the national government did well in some respects, and there was considerable coordination across levels of government, there were key failures, both in the manner of the initial abrupt and drastic national lockdown in March 2020, and in the lack of preparation and national response to the deadlier second wave of the pandemic in 2021. By contrast, subnational governments, both state and local, did better than might have been expected, especially in the face of limited resources and information. It is argued that India’s pandemic experience contradicts the “flailing state” idea that was devised to explain the country’s governmental performance in recent decades. The paper also questions the applicability of the concept of “cooperative federalism” to the Indian case. It argues that India’s federal system proved quite resilient, but can be made more effective by strengthening capacity at the local level.
Keywords:Federalism, COIVD-19, Coronavirus, India, Centralisation, Cooperative Federalsim, Flailing State
Abraham, Rosa, Amit Basole, and Surbhi Kesar (2021). Down and out? the gendered impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on India’s labour market. CSE Working Paper, Centre for Sustainable Employment, February.
Afridi, Farzana., Kanika Mahajan, and Nikita Sangwan (2021). Employment guaranteed? Social protection during a pandemic. Discussion Paper Series, IZA Institute of Labor Economics, Bonn, Germany, February.
Azim Premji University (2021). State of Working India 2021: One year of Covid-19. Centre for Sustainable Employment, Azim Premji University, Bengaluru, India, August.
Banaji, Murad, and Aashish Gupta (2022). Estimates of pandemic excess mortality in India based on civil registration data. PLOS Global Public Health. 2(12): e0000803. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0000803
Boettke, Peter and Benjamin Powell (2021). The political economy of the COVID-19 pandemic. Southern Economic Journal. 87, 1090– 1106.
Chathukulam Jos and Joseph Tharamangalam (2021). The Kerala model in the time of COVID19: Rethinking state, society and democracy. World Development. January; 137:105207.
Chattopadhyay, Rupak, Felix Knüpling, Diana Chebenova, Liam Whittington and Phillip Gonzalez (eds.) (2022). Federalism and the Response to COVID-19: A Comparative Analysis. New York: Routledge.
Chattopadhyay, Rupak, Felix Knüpling and Diana Chebenova (2022). Impact of Covid-19 on the Comparative Practice of Federalism: Some Preliminary Observations. Cadernos Gestão Pública e Cidadania, 27 (87), e85110, 1-16.
Choutagunta, Abishek, G.P. Manish, and Shruti Rajagopalan (2021). Battling COVID-19 with dysfunctional federalism: Lessons from India. Southern Economic Journal. 87, 1267– 1299.
Datta, Ushashi and Adwiteya Grover (2021). Sparring Centre-States: How Centripetal Governance During a Pandemic Has Eroded Co-operative Federalism in India, Rule of Law Journal, 2, 1-28.
DNA Web Team (2022). From Tamil Nadu to Delhi, THESE states have shut down schools amid COVID-19 surge. DNA, January 3, https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-from-tamil-nadu-to-delhi-these-states-have-shut-down-schools-amid-covid-19-surge-2926646.
Dreze, Jean, and Anmol Somanchi (2021). The Covid-19 crisis and people’s right to food. Working Paper, May 31.
Dutta, Anwesha and Harry W. Fischer (2021). The local governance of COVID-19: Disease prevention and social security in rural India. World Development, 138, 105234, 11 pp.
Ganguly, Sumit (2020) Mangling the COVID Crisis: India’s Response to the Pandemic, The Washington Quarterly, 43 (4), 105-120.
Ghosh, Abantika (2021). Bihar detected only 1 in 134 Covid cases, UP 1 in 100, Kerala 1 in six, govt. data shows, The Print, July 30, https://theprint.in/health/bihar-detected-only-1-in-134-covid-cases-up-1-in-100-kerala-1-in-six-govt-data-shows/705950/.
Gill, Navyug (2020), Essential before the Pandemic: Migrant Labour and the Politics of Language, Economic and Political Weekly, 55 (26-27), 19-21.
Greer, Scott L., Holly Jarman, Michelle Falkenbach, Elize Massard da Fonseca, Minakshi Raj and Elizabeth J. King (2021). Social policy as an integral component of pandemic response: Learning from COVID-19 in Brazil, Germany, India and the United States. Global Public Health, 16 (8-9), 1209-1222, DOI: 10.1080/17441692.2021.1916831.
Greer, Scott L., Elizabeth King and Elize Massard da Fonseca (eds.) (2021). Coronavirus Politics: The Comparative Politics and Policy of COVID-19. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Greer, Scott L., Elize Massard Fonseca, Minakshi Raj and Charley E. Willison (2022). Institutions and the politics of agency in COVID-19 response: Federalism, executive power, and public health policy in Brazil, India, and the U.S. Journal of Social Policy, 1-19, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0047279422000642.
India Today Web Desk (2022). Schools closed amid Covid-19 surge: From Odisha to Gujarat to Delhi, check latest updates here. India Today, January 8, https://www.indiatoday.in/education-today/news/story/schools-closed-amid-covid-19-surge-from-odisha-to-gujarat-to-delhi-check-latest-updates-on-school-closure-1897609-2022-01-08.
Jha, Prabhat, Yashwant Deshmukh, Chinmay Tumbe, Wilson Suraweera, Aditi Bhowmick, Sankalp Sharma, Paul Novosad, Sze Hang Fu, Leslie Newcombe, Hellen Gelband, and Patrick Brown (2022). COVID mortality in India: National survey data and health facility deaths. Science, 375, 667–671
Kaplan, Scott, Jacob Lefler and David Zilberman (2021). The political economy of COVID-19. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 44, 477-488.
Kesar, S., Abraham, R., Lahoti, R., Nath, P., and Basole, A. (2021). Pandemic, informality, and vulnerability: impact of COVID-19 on livelihoods in India. Canadian Journal of Development Studies. / Revue canadienne d'études du développement, DOI: 10.1080/02255189.2021.1890003, 20 pp.
Kumar, Himangshu, Manikantha Nataraj and Srikanta Kundu (2022). COVID-19 and Federalism in India: Capturing the Effects of State and Central Responses on Mobility. The European Journal of Development Research, 34, 2463–2492. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41287-021-00463-4.
Leffler, Christopher T., Joseph D. Lykins V, Saurav Das, Edward Yang, and Sneha Konda (222). Preliminary Analysis of Excess Mortality in India During the COVID-19 Pandemic. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 106(5), pp. 1507–1510.
Mahmood, Zaad and Achin Chakraborty (2022).: The pandemic and the state: Interrogating capacity and response to COVID-19 in West Bengal, WIDER Working Paper, The United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research (UNU-WIDER), Helsinki.
Mishra, Swasti Vardhan, Sk. Mafizul Haque and Amiya Gayen (2020), COVID-19 in India transmits from the urban to the rural. International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 35, 1623-1625, DOI: 10.1002/hpm.3047.
Mogul, Rhea, and Vedika Sud (2022). After more than 600 days shut out, Delhi’s students just want to go back to school. CNN, January 26, https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/27/india/india-delhi-schools-reopen-600-days-intl-hnk/index.html.
Mukherji, Rahul (2020). Covid vs. Democracy: India’s Illiberal Remedy, Journal of Democracy, 31 (4), 91-105.
Pareek, Urvashi and Nagendra Ambedkar Sole (2021). Institutional Responses to the Management of Covid-19 Crisis: Lessons from the Bhilwara and the Ramganj Models of Rajasthan. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 67(3): 351–364,
Pritchett, Lant (2009). Is India a Flailing State?: Detours on the Four Lane Highway to Modernization. HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series RWP09-013, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University.
Purushothaman, Uma, and John S. Moolakkattu (2021). The Politics of the COVID-19 Pandemic in India. Social Sciences, 10 (381). https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci10100381.
Raj, Minakshi (2021). India’s Response to COVID-19, in Greer et al. (eds.), Coronavirus Politics: The Comparative Politics and Policy of COVID-19, 178-195.
Rao, M. Govinda, and Nirvikar Singh (2005), The Political Economy of Federalism in India, New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Rao, M. Govinda (2022), Studies in Indian Public Finance, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Rao, Nitya, Nivedita Narain, Shuvajit Chakraborty, Arundhita Bhanjdeo and Ayesha Pattnaik (2020). Destinations Matter: Social Policy and Migrant Workers in the Times of Covid, The European Journal of Development Research, 32, 1639–1661. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41287-020-00326-4.
Ray, Debraj, and S. Subramanian. (2020). India's lockdown: An interim report. NBER Working Paper 27282, May.
Roy, Indrajit (2022). The social foundations of (in)effective states: Uttar Pradesh's response to the COVID-19 pandemic, WIDER Working Paper, No. 2022/61, The United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research (UNU-WIDER), Helsinki.
Sahoo, Niranjan, and Ambar Kumar Ghosh (2021). The COVID-19 Challenge to Indian Federalism, ORF Occasional Paper No. 322, June, Observer Research Foundation.
Sahoo, Niranjan, and Manas Ranjan Kar (2021). Evaluating Odisha’s COVID‑19 response: from quiet confidence to a slippery road. Journal of Social and Economic Development. 23 (Suppl 2): S373–S387.
Saunders, Cheryl (2022). Grappling with the pandemic: Rich insights into intergovernmental relations, Chapter 20 in Steytler, (ed.), Comparative Federalism and Covid-19: Combating the Pandemic, 375-395.
Saxena, Rekha (2022). Federalism and the COVID-19 crisis: Center-state apposite relations in India, in Chattopadhyay, et al., Federalism and the Response to COVID-19: A Comparative Analysis, 95-103.
Schmall, Emily and Sameer Yasir (2022). India Schools Stay Closed, and Hopes Fade for a Lost Generation. New York Times, January 27, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/27/world/asia/india-schools.html.
Singh, Abhijeet, Mauricio Romero and Karthik Muralidharan (2022). Covid-19 Learning Loss and Recovery: Panel Data Evidence from India. NBER Working Paper No. 30552. NBER, Cambridge, MA, October.
Singh, Ajay Kumar (2022). Pandemic governance in India: The ongoing shift to ‘national federalism,’ Chapter 15 in Steytler (ed.) Comparative Federalism and Covid-19: Combating the Pandemic, 279-297.
Singh, Balbir B., Mark Lowerison, Ryan T. Lewinson, Isabelle A. Vallerand, Rob Deardon, Játinder P. S. Gill, Baljit Singh and Herman W. Barkema (2021). Public health interventions slowed but did not halt the spread of COVID-19 in India, Transboundary and Emerging Diseases, 68, 2171– 2187. https://doi.org/10.1111/tbed.13868.
Singh, Nirvikar (2007). Fiscal Federalism and Decentralization in India, background paper for World Bank Independent Evaluation Unit, September.
Singh, Nirvikar (2021). The ‘flailing state’ revisited: States and city govts handled Covid pandemic better than Centre. Financial Express, May 3, available at https://www.financialexpress.com/opinion/the-flailing-state-revisited-states-and-city-govts-handled-covid-pandemic-better-than-centre/2244565/.
Steytler, Nico (2022). Federalism under pressure: Federal ‘health’ factors and ‘co-morbidities’, Chapter 21 in Steytler (ed.), Comparative Federalism and Covid-19: Combating the Pandemic, 396-422.
Steytler, Nico (ed.) (2022). Comparative Federalism and Covid-19: Combating the Pandemic. New York: Routledge.
Tandel, Vaidehi, Sahil Gandhi, Shaonlee Patranabis, Luís M. A. Bettencourt and Anup Malani (2021). Infrastructure, enforcement, and COVID‐19 in Mumbai slums: A first look. Journal of Regional Science, 62, 645–669.
Thomas, Vineeth (2021). Who Manages What? Covid-19 and the Centre-State Division of Responsibilities in Indian Democracy. Artha - Journal of Social Sciences, 20 (3), 1-23.
Vatta, K., Bhogal, S., Petrie, C. A., Greens, A. S., and Dixit, S. (2020). Impact of COVID-19-lockdown on Punjab agriculture. CDEIS Policy Brief Series on Punjab Economy, October.
Yang, Junyun, Leiyu Shi, Haiqian Chen, Xiaohan Wang, Jun Jiao, Manfei Yang, Meiheng Liu and Gang Sun (2022). Strategies comparison in response to the two waves of COVID-19 in the United States and India. International Journal for Equity in Health, 21 (57), 12 pp. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12939-022-01666-9.
Zaman, Sumaila (2022). Covid-19 Sub-Variant BF.7 Detected In India; Will Schools, Colleges Close? India.com, December 22, https://www.india.com/education/omicron-sub-variant-bf-7-latest-news-covid-19-advisory-issued-due-to-new-bf-7-variant-will-schools-and-colleges-close-check-latest-guidelines-here-5816537/