Unifying India’s Healthcare Markets
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.55763/ippr.2023.04.04.002Abstract
This paper delves into the structure of the healthcare market in India, contending the existence of three distinct markets: the government monopsony market, the institutional market, and the retail market. Each of these markets has unique characteristics in terms of healthcare service provisioning, pricing, and accessibility. We underscore systemic failures resulting from a lack of clarity about the structure of these markets, including disparities in service provision, lack of awareness about available services, and skewed incentives favouring private sector provisioning. We suggest unification of India's disparate healthcare markets, advocating for a more prominent role for the government. The proposed unification is a modification of the school voucher program, aimed at ensuring competitiveness on the supply side, and thereby improving service quality. While acknowledging the challenges of scale and state capacity, we argue that the proposal is worthy of further discussion and research, given its potential to harness the government's purchasing power to improve accessibility, affordability, and promote a competitive landscape that encourages innovation and quality in healthcare services.
Keywords:
Universal Health Coverage, Benevolent Monopsonist, Market Unification, HealthcareDownloads
References
Bibliography
mg, Tata. 2023. Cimivir 400mg Tablet. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.1mg.com/drugs/cimivir-400mg-tablet-236551.
About Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://pmjay.gov.in/about/pmjay.
AIHW. 2023. Health Expenditure. 23 5. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/health-welfare-expenditure/health-expenditure.
Annual Report, Department of Pharmaceuticals. Accessed 7 30, 2023. http://janaushadhi.gov.in/Data/Annual%20Report%202021-22_04052022.pdf.
Australian Government, Department of Health and Aged Care. 2023. The Australian health system. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.health.gov.au/about-us/the-australian-health-system.
Authority, National Health. 2021. National Health Benefit Package. National Health Authority.
Ayres, Ian, and John Braithwaite. 1992. “Partial-industry regulation: A monopsony standard for consumer protection.” California Law Review 13. doi:10.2307/3480815.
Balarajan, Yarlini, Selvaraj Selvaraj, and S V Subramanian. 2011. “Healthcare and Equity in India.” The Lancet 377 (9764): 505-515.
Bali, Azad Singh, and M Ramesh. 2021. “Governing healthcare in India: A policy capacity perspective.” International Review of Administrative Sciences 87 (2): 275-293.
Bank, World. 2023. Current Health Expenditure (% of GDP) - Australia. 7 4. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.CHEX.GD.ZS?locations=AU.
Case No. 39/2012, CCI. Accessed 7 30, 2023. http://164.100.58.95/sites/default/files/392012T_0.pdf.
CCI. 2015. Notice u/s 6 (2) of the Competition Act, 2002 given by: JK Tyre & Industries Limited and J.K. Asia Pacific (S) Pte Ltd. October. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.cci.gov.in/sites/default/files/Notice_order_document/C-2015-10-322.pdf.
CGHS Dashboard. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://cghs.nic.in/dashboard/dashboardnew.jsp.
CGHS. 2023. Facilities available under CGHS. 30 July. Accessed Kuly 30, 2023. https://cghs.gov.in/CghsGovIn/faces/ViewPage.xhtml.
CGHS package rate Delhi & NCR . Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://cghs.gov.in/CghsGovIn/faces/ViewPage.xhtml?id=MzYwNA==.
CGHS. 2023. Restricted Drugs/Medicines. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://cghs.nic.in/ls_online.jsp.
Corporation, Employees' State Insurance. 2023. ESIC. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.esic.gov.in/.
D'Cruze, Natasha Agnes. 2020. “Risky Insurance: The Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana in Jharkhand.” Economic and Political Weekly, 07 11.
Directorate For Financial And Enterprise Affairs, OECD. 2012. Market Definition. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.oecd.org/daf/competition/Marketdefinition2012.pdf.
D'Souza, Royson. 2023. Surgical Care in Rural India – A Poor Man’s Nightmare. 12 4. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://nivarana.org/2023/04/12/surgical-care-in-india/.
Dutt, Anona. 2023. Doctors vs Rajasthan’s Right to Health Bill. 30 3. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-health/doctors-vs-rajasthans-right-to-health-bill-8524518/.
ESIC. 2018. Atal Beemit Vyakti Kalyan Yojana. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://www.esic.nic.in/attachments/circularfile/93e904d2e3084d65fdf7793e9098d125.pdf.
—. 2023. ESIC Applicability. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://www.esic.in/en/web/esic/coverage.
—. 2023. ESIC at a Glance. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://www.esic.nic.in/attachments/files/esic%20at%20a%20glance.pdf.
—. 2023. ESIC Dashboard. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.esic.in/Dashboard/Default.aspx.
Express, Financial. 2023. ESIC scheme and its benefits: Here is everything you need to know. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://www.financialexpress.com/money/esic-scheme-and-its-benefits-know-everything-you-need-to-know/2098893/.
Feenstra, Robert C, and Alan M Taylor. 2017. International Macroeconomics. New York: Worth Publishers.
Frankel, Marcel. 2019. Health Care Systems and Their Patients: An International Perspective. Routledge.
Froot, Kenneth A, and K Rogoff. 2019. “The Law of One Price over 700 Years.” Annals of Economics and Finance 1-35. doi:10.3386/w5132.
Fund, The Commonwealth. 2020. International Health Care System Profiles: Canada. 5 6. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/international-health-policy-center/countries/canada.
—. 2020. International Health Care System Profiles: Singapore. 5 6. Accessed 7 21, 2023. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/international-health-policy-center/countries/singapore.
Fund, The King's. 2023. Key Facts and Figures about the NHS. 4 5. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/key-facts-figures-nhs.
Gaffney, Adam, and Danny McCormick. 2017. “The Affordable Care Act: implications for health-care equity.” The Lancet 389 (10077): 1442-1452.
Harker, Rachael. 2012. NHS Funding and Expenditure. 3 4. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://fullfact.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/SN00724-NHS-spending.pdf.
Health Directorate, Indian Railways. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://indianrailways.gov.in/railwayboard/uploads/directorate/health/healthcare.jsp.
India, Competition Commission of. 2008. All India Tyre Dealers Federation vs Tyre Manufacturers. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://cci.gov.in/antitrust/orders/details/447/0.
—. 2002. The Competition Act. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.cci.gov.in/images/legalframeworkact/en/the-competition-act-20021652103427.pdf.
Jha, Durgesh Nandan. 2017. Retail margin on generic drugs is as high as 1,000%, claims a study. 19 April. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://health.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/pharma/retail-margin-on-generic-drugs-is-as-high-as-1000-claims-a-study/58251605.
Jones, Karen, Julian Forder, J Caiels, E Welch, C Glendinning, and K Windle. 2013. “Personalization in the health care system: do personal health budgets have an impact on outcomes and cost?.” ournal of health services research & policy 59-67.
Klein, Ezra. 2020. In the UK’s health system, rationing isn’t a dirty word. 28 1. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.vox.com/2020/1/28/21074386/health-care-rationing-britain-nhs-nice-medicare-for-all.
Lagomarsino, Gina, Alice Garabrant, Atikah Adyas, Richard Muga, and Nathaniel Otoo. 2012. “Moving towards universal health coverage: health insurance reforms in nine developing countries in Africa and Asia.” The Lancet 380 (9845): 933-943.
Lahariya, Chandrakant. 2020. “Access, utilization, perceived quality, and satisfaction with health services at Mohalla (Community) Clinics of Delhi, India.” ournal of Family Medicine and Primary Care.
Luthra, Tannuj. 2023. Informal Healthcare Providers: Family Doctors to the Poor. 10 6. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://nivarana.org/2023/06/10/informal-healthcare-providers-in-india/.
Madhiwalla, Neha, Sanjay A Pai, and Nobhojit Roy. 2007. “Drug promotional practices in Mumbai: a qualitative study.” Indian journal of medical ethics 57-61.
Mahajan, Arnav, Wuttipong Tirakotai, and Masayaanon Patcharapim. 2023. “The hidden costs of universal health coverage: solutions from the fight against catastrophic healthcare expenditure in Thailand.” BMJ Global health.
Mankiw, Gregory N. 2019. Principles of Economics. 9th. Cengage.
Maria, Portela, Conceiçao A Silva, and Emmanuel Thanassoulis. 2014. “Economic efficiency when prices are not fixed: disentangling quantity and price efficiency.” Omega 36-44.
Meghani, Varsha. 2020. Is PM Modi's Ayushman Bharat too ambitious to succeed? 23 1. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://www.forbesindia.com/article/budget-2020/is-pm-modi039s-ayushman-bharat-too-ambitious-to-succeed/57279/1.
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. 2023. National health Accounts, Estimates for India. 11 April. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://main.mohfw.gov.in/sites/default/files/5NHA_19-20_dt%2019%20April%202023_web_version_1.pdf.
Muralidharan, Karthik, and Venkatesh Sundararaman. 2015. “The aggregate effect of school choice: Evidence from a two-stage experiment in India.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 1011-1066.
Nagarajan, Rema. 2022. Is the fall in out-of-pocket health spending a mirage? 6 10. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/is-the-fall-in-out-of-pocket-health-spending-a-mirage/articleshow/94669701.cms.
Neelakantan, Murali. 2015. “The Interplay between Competition Law and Intellectual Property Rights in the Indian Healthcare Sector.” NLS Business Law Review 31.
News, City Air. 2023. Hospitals must be health insurance companies: Dr. Devishetty. 15 5. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.cityairnews.com/content/hospitals-must-be-health-insurance-companies-dr-devishetty.
Ogden, Joy. 2017. “QALY's and their role in the NICE decision-making process.” Prescriber, 4 ed.: 41-43.
Oommen, Kurian. 2015. Financing Healthcare for All in India: Towards a Common Goal. Oxfam.
Parthasarathi, R, and S P Sinha. 2016. “Towards a better health care delivery system: the Tamil Nadu model.” Indian journal of community medicine: official publication of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine 302.
Pindyck, S R, and D L Rubinfield. 2013. Microeconomics. Pearson.
Pradhan Mantri Bhartiya Janaushadhi Pariyojana (PMBJP). Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://pharmaceuticals.gov.in/schemes/pradhan-mantri-bhartiya-janaushadhi-pariyojana-pmbjp.
Pradhan Mantri Bhartiya Janaushadhi Pariyojana 2015. Accessed 7 30, 2023. http://janaushadhi.gov.in/pmjy.aspx.
PRS. 2023. Demand for Grants 2023-24 Analysis : Health and Family Welfare. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://prsindia.org/budgets/parliament/demand-for-grants-2023-24-analysis-health-and-family-welfare.
Rajagopalan, Shruti, and Alexander Tabarrok. 2019. “Premature Imitation and India's Flailing State.” The Independent Review 165-186.
Rajasthan Right to Healthcare Act. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://rajswasthya.nic.in/PDF/94%20Dt.08.03.2022%20Website.pdf.
Rawlins, Michael. 2009. “The NICE way of influencing health spending: a conversation with Sir Michael Rawlins. Interview by Nicholas Timmins.” Health Affairs 1360-1365.
Rungsheng, Du. 2010. “The course of China's rural reform.” In Narratives of Chinese economic reforms: How does China cross the river?, 15-29.
Ruthven, Orlanda, Jonathan Murdoch, and Stuart Rutherford. 2009. Portfolios of the Poor. Princeton University Press.
Sanders, Bernie. 2023. Public Investment, Private Greed. Majority Staff Report.
Sasse, Tom. 2020. NHS Procurement. 22 4. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/article/explainer/nhs-procurement.
Scott, Dylan. 2020. Taiwan’s single-payer success story — and its lessons for America. 13 1. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.vox.com/health-care/2020/1/13/21028702/medicare-for-all-taiwan-health-insurance.
—. 2020. The Netherlands has universal health insurance — and it’s all private. 17 1. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/1/17/21046874/netherlands-universal-health-insurance-private.
Scott, Dylan, Ezra Klein, and Tara Golshan. 2020. Everybody Covered. 12 2. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.vox.com/2020/1/13/21055327/everybody-covered.
Sen, Amartya. 2015. Universal healthcare: The Affordable Dream. 6 1. Accessed 7 31, 2023. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jan/06/-sp-universal-healthcare-the-affordable-dream-amartya-sen.
Sharma, Priyanka. 2023. Premium rates for PM-JAY to rise for first time since ’18. 31 5. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://www.livemint.com/news/india/nha-plans-to-revise-premium-for-world-s-largest-health-assurance-scheme-pradhan-mantri-jan-arogya-yojana-ab-pm-jay-in-new-delhi-11685553739511.html.
Shi, Leiyu, and Douglas A Singh. 2014. Delivering Healthcare in America: A Systems Approach. Jones and Bartlett Learning.
Singh, Pushpendra, and Virendra Kumar. 2017. “Insurance coverage under different health schemes in Uttar Pradesh, India.” Clinical Epidemiology and Global Health 33-39.
Sundaram, T. 2018. Opinion: Modicare is more an election gimmick than a real solution to India’s health needs. 5 2. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://scroll.in/pulse/867524/modicare-is-more-an-election-gimmick-than-a-real-solution-to-indias-health-needs.
Thaler, Richard H, and O A Lamont. 2002. “Anomalies: The law of one price in financial markets.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 191-202.
Thawani, V, A Mani, and N Upmanyu. 2017. “Why the Jan Aushadhi Scheme has Lost its Steam in India.” Journal of Pharmacology and Pharmacotherapeutics 134-136.
Upadhyay, Ankita, and Kaunain M Sheriff. 2023. Bypassing Ayushman Bharat, doctor at top Central hospital duped patients, made killing on implants. Accessed 7 30, 2023. https://indianexpress.com/article/express-exclusive/bypassing-ayushman-bharat-doctor-at-top-central-hospital-duped-patients-made-killing-on-implants-8849183/.
Veillard, Jeremy, Irfan Dhalla, Omid Fekri, and Niek Klazinga. 2015. “Measuring outcomes in the Canadian Health sector: driving better value from healthcare.” CD Howe Institute Commentary, 438.
Welfare, Department of Ex-Servicement. 2023. FAQ. Accessed July 30, 2023. https://www.desw.gov.in/en/faq#:~:text=Who%20are%20eligible%20to%20become%20ECHS%20members%3F&text=Armed%20Forces%20Veterans%20(AFV)%20drawing,drawing%20Ordinary%2FSpecial%20family%20pension.
Welfare, Ministry of Health and Family. 2013. Annual Report, 2012-13. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, India.
Wyber, Rosemary, Samuel Vaillancourt, William Perry, Priya Mannava, Temitope Folaranmi, and Leo Anthony Celi. 2015. “Big data in global health: improving health in low-and middle-income countries.” Bulletin of the World Health Organization 203-208.
Yadapalli, Kusuma S, Manisha Pal, and Bontha V Babu. 2018. “Health insurance: Awareness, utilization, and its determinants among the urban poor in Delhi, India.” Journal of epidemiology and global health 69.
