Examining exclusions in the Public Distribution System
A policy ethics perspective on ensuring the right to food
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.55763/ippr.2025.06.01.004Abstract
Article 21 of the Indian Constitution guarantees the right to life, with the right to food being a fundamental aspect of this guarantee. Policies concerning beneficiary coverage and Aadhaar biometric identification have led to significant exclusions within the Public Distribution System, which undermine this right. This raises critical ethical questions regarding these policies. The ethical framework embedded in the Indian Constitution has substantial implications for contemporary policymaking. How can policy ethics ensure the right to food—the right to life—for all individuals? This study assesses policies through evidence-based research, centred on the implementation of the PDS in Nagaland, India. Exclusions primarily stem from the interplay of census and identity politics, coupled with a technological determinism largely influenced by centralized state control and surveillance. This often overshadows constitutional values and objectives in policy decisions, compromising the foundational ethical principles of policymaking. Policy formulation grounded in reliable population data, targeted inclusion initiatives, flexible identity verification, and dedicated support for the most vulnerable groups is essential for ensuring inclusivity. Empowering local institutions and community-led organizations, particularly self-help groups in the management of welfare programs, can significantly enhance inclusivity. Public policies must rekindle the radical spirit of the Constitution and actualize the ethical framework envisaged within it.
Keywords:
Aadhaar, exclusion, constitution, policy ethics, PDS, right to foodDownloads
References
Baxi, Upendra. 1992. The Indian Constitution: Has it stood the test of time?., edited by C.K Jain. Constitution of India: In Precept and Practice. CBS Publishers & Distributors. New Delhi.
Bhagat, R. B. 2012. “Census enumeration, religious identity and communal polarization in India.” Asian Ethnicity, 14 (4): 434–448. https://doi.org/10.1080/14631369.2012.710079
Bhardwaj, Anjali, Nikhil Dey, Jean Dreze, and Reetika Khera. 2016. “PDS in Danger.” Economic and Political Weekly 51 (38): 4.
Carswell, Grace, and Geert De Neve. 2022. “Transparency, exclusion and mediation: how digital and biometric technologies are transforming social protection in Tamil Nadu, India.” Oxford Development Studies, 50 (2): 126-141.
Cengiz, Firat. 2023. “Blockchain governance and governance via blockchain: decentralized utopia or centralized dystopia?.” Policy Design and Practice, 6 (4): 446-464.
Chaudhuri, Bidisha. 2021. “Distant, opaque and seamful: seeing the state through the workings of Aadhaar in India.” Information Technology for Development, 27 (1): 37-49.
Cohen, Andrew I. 2015. Philosophy, Ethics, and Public Policy. An Introduction. New York: Routledge.
Daniyal, Shoaib. 2023. “The India fix: why is India suddenly unable to conduct its regular census?” Scroll.in, January 16, 2023. https://scroll.in/article/1041927/the-india-fix-why-is-india-suddenly-unable-to-conduct-its-regular-census
Dreze, Jean, Khalid, Nazar, Khera, Reetika, & Somanchi, Anmol. 2017. Aadhaar and Food Security in Jharkhand: Pain without Gain?, Economic and Political Weekly, 52 (50): 50-59.
Economic and Political Weekly. 2016. “Battle Far From Won: Food insecurities remain even as more states begin implementing.” Economic and Political Weekly, 51 (26/27): 8.
Economic and Political Weekly. 2015. “A Legal Vacuum: The Supreme Court has failed to protect citizens from government illegality on Aadhaar.” Economic and Political Weekly, 50 (34): 7-8.
Easton, David. 1950. Harold Lasswell; Policy Scientist for a Democratic Society, The Journal of Politics, 12(3): 450-477. https://doi.org/10.2307/2126297
Ellul, Jacques. 1964. The Technological Society. New York: Vintage books.
Fernandez, Rudolph Lambert. 2024. “Why India’s Delayed Census Evokes Anxiety More Than Anticipation.” The Diplomat, August 26, 2024. https://thediplomat.com/2024/08/why-indias-delayed-census-evokes-anxiety-more-than-anticipation/
Francis Coralie Mullin v. Union Territory of Delhi, 2 S.C.R. 516 (1981). https://digiscr.sci.gov.in/admin/judgement_file/judgement_pdf/1981/volume%202/Part%20I/francis%20coralie%20mullin_the%20administrator,%20union%20territory%20of%20delhi_1699004692.pdf
Gajendragadkar, P.B. 1969. The Constitution of India. Its Philosophy and Basic Postulates. Nairobi: Oxford University Press.
Gill, Mehar Singh. 2007. “Politics of population census in India.” Economic and Political Weekly, 42 (3): 241-249.
Justice k. S. Puttaswamy (retd.) & ANR. vs. Union of India & ORS, 8 S.C.R. 1 (2018). https://digiscr.sci.gov.in/admin/judgement_file/judgement_pdf/2018/volume%208/Part%20I/justice%20k.%20s.%20puttaswamy%20(retd.)%20&%20anr._union%20of%20india%20&%20ors._1698832759.pdf
Scott, J. C. 1998. Seeing like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Jayal, Niraja. 2024. Rights and Citizenship. In The oxford handbook of Indian politics, edited by Sumit Ganguly and Eswaran Sridharan. Oxford University Press.
Jayal, Niraja Gopal. 2022. “Reinventing the Republic: Faith and Citizenship in India.” Studies in Indian Politics, 10(1): 14–30. DOI: 10.1177/23210230221082799
Jayal, Niraja Gopal. 2019. Reconfiguring Citizenship in Contemporary India, South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies, 42 (1): 33-50.
Jayal, Niraja Gopal, ed. 2001. Democracy in India. Oxford University Press. New Delhi.
Jha, Manish K, and Pushpendra Kumar. 2016. “Homeless Migrants in Mumbai: Life and Labour in Urban Space.” Economic and Political Weekly, 51 (26/27): 69-75, 77.
Koya, Shaffi Fazaludeen, and Sushant Kumar. 2023. “India’s indefinitely delayed census.” The Lancet, 402 (10406): 962-963. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)01477-0
Khera, Reetika. 2017. “Impact of Aadhaar on Welfare Programmes.” Economic and Political Weekly, 52 (50): 61-70
Khera, Reetika. 2011. “The UID Project and Welfare Schemes.” Economic and Political Weekly, 46 (9): 38-43.
Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, 2 S.C.R. 621 (1978). https://digiscr.sci.gov.in/admin/judgement_file/judgement_pdf/1978/volume%202/Part%20I/maneka%20gandhi_union%20of%20india%20_1700557554.pdf
Masiero, Silvia, and Savita Bailur. 2021. “Digital identity for development: The quest for justice and a research agenda.” Information Technology for Development, 27 (1): 1-12.
Masiero, Silvia, and Soumyo Das. 2019. “Datafying anti-poverty programmes: implications for data justice.” Information, Communication & Society, 22 (7): 916-933.
Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution. National Food Security Act, 2013 (NFSA) provides coverage of 75% rural and 50% urban population. PIB. February 10, 2023. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1897933 accessed 14 December, 2024
Nayak, N, and S. Nehra. 2017. “Accessing the Right to Food in Delhi.” Economic and Political Weekly, 52 (23): 2349-8846.
Nayar, Pramod K. 2012. “'I Sing the Body Biometric': Surveillance and Biological Citizenship.” Economic and Political Weekly, 47 (32): 19-22.
National Council of Applied Economic Research. 2015. “Evaluation Study of Targeted Public Distribution System in Selected States.” https://www.ncaer.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/1460106533TPDS-140316.pdf
Ngullie, O. Grace, and Arib Ansari. 2021. “Impact of the Pandemic on Livelihood and Food Security: An Empirical Analysis of the PDS in Delhi.” Indian Journal of Public Administration, 67 (3): 314-323. https://doi.org/10.1177/00195561211045797
Ngullie, O. Grace. 2018.The Politics and Governance of Social Policies in Delhi: Comparing Cash and In-kind Transfers. https://www.thehinducentre.com/publications/policy-report/article24542070.ece/binary/Policy%20Report%20No.%2022.pdf
Orr, Susan, and James Johnson. 2019. “Models, mechanisms, metrics: the entanglement of methods of policy inquiry with democratic possibilities.” In The Routledge Handbook of Ethics and Public Policy, edited by Annabelle Lever and Andrei Poama. New York: Routledge.
Ostrom, Elinor. 2015. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press.
Pritchett, Lant. 2009. “Is India a flailing state? Detours on the four lane highway to modernization.” HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series RWP09-013, Harvard University. Cambridge, MA. https://bpb-us-e1.wpmucdn.com/websites.harvard.edu/dist/c/104/files/2023/04/Pritchett-India-Flailing-State.pdf
Provis, Chris. 2007. “Ethics and Issues in Public Policy.” Policy and Society, 26 (3): 21-33.
Rao, Ursula. 2013. “Biometric Marginality: UID and the Shaping of Homeless Identities in the City.” Economic and Political Weekly, 48 (13): 71-77.
Rao, Ursula, and Vijayanka Nair. 2019. “Aadhaar: Governing with Biometrics.” South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies, 42 (3): 469-481.
Sen, Amartya. 2009. The Idea of Justice. Harvard University Press.
Shapiro, Sidney A. & Schroeder, Christopher H. 2008. Beyond cost-benefit analysis: A pragmatic reorientation. Harvard Environmental Law Review, 32 (2): 433-502.
Surendranath, Anup. 2016. “Life and Personal Liberty”. In The Oxford Handbook of the Indian Constitution, edited by Sujit Choudhry, Madhav Khosla, and Pratap Bhanu Mehta. UK: Oxford University Press.
Whitby, Andrew. 2020. The sum of the people. How the census has shaped nations, from the ancient world to the modern age. Basic books.
Wolff, Jonathan. 2019. Method in philosophy and public policy: applied philosophy versus engaged philosophy, edited by Annabelle Lever and Andrei Poama. The Routledge Handbook of Ethics and Public Policy. New York: Routledge.
Young, Kaliya. 2019. “Key Differences Between the U.S. Social Security System and India’s Aadhaar System.” New America. https://www.newamerica.org/fellows/reports/anthology-working-papers-new-americas-us-india-fellows/key-differences-between-the-us-social-security-system-and-indias-aadhaar-system-kaliya-young/
